Click
on site plan for additional images:
This 1999 project was the product of a charrette led by the
Anderson Bess Design Group, a joint venture of Thursday Associates and Anderson
Lamb & Associates. The site is the Henry Davis Property, a 536-acre parcel
located about 10 miles east of Grand Rapids, Michigan, in Ada Township
approximately 3 miles north of the unincorporated Village of Ada. In its
environmental, economic, and social implications, the proposal here presented is
unique in the post-War history of real estate development in Western Michigan.
The property is in a growth corridor, and sits in the midst
of a largely rural and agricultural landscape that has already begun to be
transformed by conventional sprawl development of one-to-three acre/s per
dwelling unit construction. The site is occupied by the Davis Farm, a
combination of agricultural land, forests, meadows, and regulated wetlands; as
well as an operative 200-acre gravel mine bordered by Pettis Road to the
southwest. Contiguous to the northwest portion of the site is a 40-acre horse
farm; and contiguous to that, at the southwest corner of the intersection of
Pettis and Knapp Roads, is a 115-acre parcel owned by the Forest Hills Public
School District for the future development of as many as three new schools
covering grades K-12. The Davis Property is currently zoned as a "special
use parcel," with anticipated permissible overall density of one dwelling
unit per acre. It was the desire of the developer client to match or exceed the
legally allowable density, but to preserve the sites natural amenities and make
them available to the public in a manner that conventional sprawl development
would not have allowed.
In keeping with these intentions, the Anderson Bess Design
Group took a holistic approach to the work so that in addition to being an
economically viable human settlement it would also do the following things: 1)
preserve and enhance the most significant features of the parcel’s existing
natural and agricultural landscape, and make much of it publicly accessible; 2)
restore the scarred landscape of the gravel mine; 3) create a mixed-use,
mixed-age, and mixed-income physical environment of pedestrian-friendly public
and private places; and 4) achieve all these things in an environmentally
responsible way, paying special attention to issues of fresh water supply, waste
water disposal, and traffic congestion. Our design has attempted to realize
these objectives in the following ways. . . .
Davis Farm Development (100 dwelling units, 330
acres): The most scenic and picturesque portions of the site are the natural and
agricultural landscapes of the Davis Farm. These we have attempted to preserve
and highlight by creating large estate lots and small clusters of residential
development around several of the Farm’s most significant features, which we
have simultaneously attempted to preserve; and also by leaving portions of the
working (agricultural) farm undisturbed, potentially available for lease as
subscription farmland. Our proposed developments include: High Point,
estate lots in the northwest corner of the Farm near the community well head and
the site’s highest point, which features a public overlook of the site towards
the southwest, as well as large tracts of publicly accessible rural preserves; Davis
Hollow, a cluster of residences located on the eastern portion of the Farm
near the existing Davis homestead and farm buildings, also featuring rural
preserves as well as a community garden; The Stables, a combination of
estate lots and clustered residences in the central portion of the Farm property
near the existing Davis Farm stables, surrounded by rural preserves and
agricultural land and adjacent to a stream corridor; and Crescent Meadow,
a crescent-row of houses fronting an existing open meadow defined by mature
trees, with a stream corridor to the rear of the houses. Our proposed
developments not only preserve these several existing features of the Davis
Farm; they also make them publicly accessible to both residents and other
members of the community through the creation of a series of pedestrian and
equestrian trails that weave throughout the public areas and rural preserves of
the Davis Farm development.
Gravel Mine Development (700 dwelling units, 200 acres):
The gravel mine is the aesthetic "scar" on the Davis Property
landscape; and it is here that we propose not a preservation of the site’s
existing qualities but rather their transformation and restoration by means of
higher-density, mixed-use village development. This area is laid out in a
traditional village pattern of streets, blocks, and squares that accommodate and
provide settings for a variety of civic buildings (library, meeting hall,
church, water tower, community theater), commercial activities, and house types.
The two main streets are Basin Street, which from its intersection with
Pettis Avenue runs northwest about a half mile and terminates at the reflecting
pond on axis with the community theater, and is fronted by houses, storefronts,
and the village meeting hall; and (both accessed from, and one block northeast
of, Pettis Avenue) Central Avenue, which runs about a half mile from the
church at the southeast to the water tower at the northwest and is a more formal
street, also fronted by storefronts near its intersection with Basin Street and
by houses elsewhere along its length.
Fresh Water Supply: Our civil engineers identified, prior
to the charrette, two possible on-site locations for wells sufficient to supply
the fresh water needs of the project, one to the western part of the site just
north east of the bend in Pettis Road, the other in the northeastern portion of
the site near its high point. As the site design issues became clearer over the
course of the charrette, the latter site was chosen as the preferred location
for the well.
Constructed Wetlands Wastewater Treatment: All
wastewater is being treated on site by means of constructed wetlands and bio-fields,
an environmentally-friendly water purification process that is both
cost-competitive and able to be built incrementally as the village is finished
out. The constructed wetlands cells, which can be composed and constructed in
either regular or irregular patterns, are comprised of various selected plant
materials; and on our plan are located just north of the library, adjacent to
(but separated from) some regulated and reserved natural wetlands and forest.
The constructed wetlands cells are dry at the top surface and odorless, and will
require minimal private maintenance from the developer. The cells can stand
alone or be surrounded by and / or interspersed with other annual or perennial
plantings to make an appealing aesthetic contribution to the community. The
second and final location of the wastewater treatment process is the bio-field,
tall prairie grasses which in the village plan are located in the westernmost
block of the northern most quadrant of the village, just east of Pettis Road and
a row of new cherry trees.
Traffic Congestion: Development of the Davis Property
will increase the net amount of traffic in the vicinity, but significantly less
than would conventional suburban development of the same site at the density
that its current zoning allows. We have identified two specific ways of dealing
with traffic congestion. The first is the inherent efficiency of traditional
neighborhood design, which (owing to its very nature of mixing various uses
within pedestrian proximity of one another) reduces the average daily number of
trips individuals take in their cars. The second is the construction of three modern
roundabouts, the most important one of which would be at the intersection of
Pettis and Knapp Roads north of the site, just northwest of the 115-acre Forest
Hills Public School District property. Modern roundabouts perform simultaneously
three important functions: 1) increased traffic capacity; 2) traffic calming;
and 3) increased pedestrian safety. In particular, the roundabout proposed for
the corner of Knapp and Pettis will not only more efficiently handle both
existing traffic and traffic generated by the Davis Property development
than the current four-way stop; it will also be able (and necessary) to handle
the traffic generated by any new school construction undertaken by the Forest
Hills Public School District.
Public Open Space: We have endeavored to create and / or
preserve a variety of open spaces that are truly public. On the Davis Farm site
these include over 200 acres of forests, meadows, regulated wetlands, and
agricultural land accessible by various pedestrian and equestrian trails. In the
village proposed for the Gravel Mine site the public open space includes a
variety of streets, civic and residential squares, constructed wetlands and
bio-fields, and the allee’ of cherry trees proposed along Pettis Avenue. It
cannot be emphasized too strongly that the preservation and public accessibility
of this quantity of open space is inconceivable within the norms of conventional
suburban development.